Tag Archives: Zillur Rahman Haider

‘Who Is Responsible?’ Book on Partition Launched in New Delhi

NEW DELHI :

New Delhi: 

A book titled “Zimmedar Kaun? Taqseem-e-Hind Ka Muqaddama Insaaf Ki Adalat Mein” (Who is Responsible? The Case of the Partition of India in the Court of Justice) was released by well-known Islamic scholar Hazrat Maulana Khalil-ur-Rahman Sajjad Nomani, at the Jasola Hotel here on Friday.

Authored by researcher Muhammad Sujood-ul-Aziz Al-Qasmi, the publication offers an unbiased, objective examination of the 1947 Partition of India. Utilizing primary documentary evidence, historical facts, and key correspondence, the author frames Partition as a courtroom trial to deliver a fair analysis of the respective roles played by the British Raj, the All-India Muslim League, and the Indian National Congress.

Key speakers—including veteran journalist Dr. Zafarul-Islam Khan and senior journalist Masoom Moradabadi—lauded the author’s painstaking research and the book’s scholarly depth. Attended by prominent local religious figures, distinguished women, and numerous students, the gathering widely praised the volume as a landmark contribution to historical and socio-political literature.

Eminent senior Urdu journalist, columnist, and editor of “Jadeed Khabar”, Mr. Masoom Moradabadi, brought a sharp journalistic and analytical lens to the podium. Opening his address, he reflected on the purpose behind literary works, noting that while Urdu media frequently publishes book reviews, truly purposeful and substantive contributions remain rare. The supreme merit of Al-Qasmi’s work lies in its rigorous research methodology. Eschewing oral hearsay and unverified folklore, the author navigated authentic Urdu, English, and historical archival sources with academic discipline, producing an investigative masterpiece that warrants the highest commendation.

Transitioning to the broader context of Partition historiography, Moradabadi challenged the conventional narrative that places Muslims exclusively in the dock. He drew attention to significant analytical works published across the border, such as Syed Hasan Riaz’s monumental 1,400-page volume ‘Pakistan Naguzeer Tha’ and Chaudhry Khaliquzzaman’s ‘Shahrah-e-Pakistan’, alongside notable Indian contributions like Kamleshwar’s ‘Kitne Pakistan’. Addressing the core question of why this retrospective debate matters nearly eighty years post-independence, he underscored that the Partition remains one of history’s worst human catastrophes, claiming nearly a million innocent lives.

While political theorists often argue that a unified nation would have spared Indian Muslims their current socio-political vulnerability, historical realities demand deeper contemplation. Pakistan, founded upon religious nationalism as a “Mamlekat-e-Khudadad,” fractured along linguistic lines in 1971 with the emergence of Bangladesh. Highlighting the irony inherent in majoritarian political demands, Moradabadi shared his frequent counsel to proponents of a mono-cultural state: “If you wish to reshape India, as a “Hindu Rashtra” look first at the complex realities and fragmentation haunting Pakistan’s history!”—a challenge that invariably leaves proponents silent.

Detailing the grim socio-economic realities of migrant communities (Muhajirs) in urban centers like Islamabad and Karachi, he emphasized that the sacrifices underpinning Pakistan’s creation were heavily compromised by feudal hegemony and elite governance. The systemic marginalization faced by minority and migrant populations across borders serves as a poignant reminder of the failures of majoritarian statecraft. In India, the continuous weaponization of Partition to demand questioning of community loyalty constitutes a malicious scheme by fringe extremist elements. Moradabadi concluded with an earnest recommendation: to bridge cultural divides and counter misinformation effectively, this stellar research work must be translated into Hindi and edited by linguistic experts to reach a broader national readership where the book trade thrives.

Eminent Islamic scholar and founder-editor of The Milli Gazette, Dr. Zafarul-Islam Khan delivered a keynote address characterized by intellectual rigor and fearless candor. Opening his remarks, Dr. Khan congratulated the author for steering clear of emotional rhetoric and adopting a balanced, scholarly methodology that refreshes historical debate.

Focusing on community communication failures, Dr. Khan observed that Indian Muslims have historically failed to articulate their grievances and historical narrative effectively to the global and national mainstream. Whatever documentation existed remained confined to Urdu—a language that itself became a victim of Partition’s linguistic reorganization. Had unity been preserved, Urdu would likely have stood alongside Hindi as a national co-official language. While English persists as an administrative bridge for non-Hindi speaking southern and eastern states, Northern India’s “Cow Belt” has overwhelmingly adopted Hindi as its vernacular baseline. Despite these shifts, Dr. Khan stressed the urgent moral imperative to protect and propagate Urdu, noting that after Arabic, the richest theological and literary heritage of Islamic scholarship resides within Urdu texts, surpassing even Persian in certain analytical compilations.

Reflecting on constitutional history, Dr. Khan recounted the tragic marginalization of Urdu during Constituent Assembly voting, where a initial majority favouring Urdu was overturned due to political compromises. He recalled that Begum Ezaz Rasul’s casting vote in the Constituent Assembly made Hindi the national language but she failed to extract the concession to make Urdu the second official language. He recalled Sardar Patel’s historic assurances regarding minority integration and political reservations and protections that minority leadership voluntarily relinquished in good faith within a secular framework, only to face systemic erosion decades later. Contrasting this trajectory with international models, he cited the Jewish community’s systematic efforts to memorialize historical persecution through literature, cinema, and rigorous legal protections across Western Europe. While external political actions continue to reshape global sympathies, minority communities in pluralistic societies must master modern bridge languages—specifically English —to project their contributions and historical truths accurately.

Challenging simplistic attributions of blame for the Partition, Dr. Khan offered a nuanced structural analysis. The tragedy cannot be reduced to a single culprit; colonial conspiracies played a decisive role. British imperial strategy abhorred the prospect of leaving behind a monolithic superpower comprising India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh—an economic titan commanding a huge chunk of global GDP. Colonial historiography, spearheaded by chroniclers like Elliot and Dawson post-1857, systematically injected communal poison into historical texts. In reality, the Mughal rulers and Muslim dynastic governance integrated disparate principalities into a cohesive economic and administrative grid stretching from Kabul to south India. Concluding his address, Dr. Khan endorsed the book as a monumental, objective contribution that paves the way for intellectual clarity. He suggested that the book should be translated at least into Hindi.

In his visionary presidential address, renowned Islamic scholar Hazrat Maulana Khalil-ur-Rahman Sajjad Nomani elevated the discourse from political critique to civilizational psychology and spiritual resilience. Analyzing the dynamics of societal rise and fall, Maulana Nomani emphasized that navigating severe socio-political adversity requires a balanced, composed psychological state. Despair, panic, and emotional reactivity cloud intellectual clarity and paralyze collective progress. Just as individuals experience biological cycles of health and illness, nations traverse historical epochs of ascendancy and decline governed by universal divine laws.

Addressing the contemporary hopelessness gripping the Muslim community, the Maulana asserted that the current cycle of decline is neither permanent nor absolute. Prophetic traditions explicitly outline periods of trial for the Ummah, but they equally promise a grand renaissance—a ‘Nishat-e-Saaniya’—wherein past prestige and moral leadership will be restored through divine providence. Achieving this revival, however, demands systematic intellectual, moral, and emotional training. During times of intense crisis, leadership must extinguish fear, kindle hope, and foster critical self-accountability.

Maulana Nomani cautioned against internal inferiority complexes fuelled by historical ignorance and unverified propaganda. The persistent self-doubt among the younger generation—questioning whether elders erred in pursuing Partition—stems from a superficial reading of history. A rigorous historical inquiry must examine the complex web of British divide-and-rule tactics, broken political pacts, and compelling existential pressures that forced communities into corners. He praised young scholar Muhammad Sujood-ul-Aziz Al-Qasmi for stepping forward with methodological rigor to counter emotionally charged, rhetorical narratives with archival documentation.

Presenting an extensive and deeply reflective introduction to his work, author Maulana Muhammad Sujood-ul-Aziz Al-Qasmi addressed the audience with an impassioned discourse on the imperatives of historical truth and collective memory. Nearly eighty years have passed since the partition of the country, yet the socio-political climate shows no signs of healing or progressive evolution. Muslims—who shed the most blood and offered unprecedented sacrifices for the liberation of their beloved motherland—find themselves regrettably thrust into the dock of public scrutiny today. An insidious indictment is consistently levied against them, branding them as the primary culprits and sole architects of the Partition of India. The rhetoric has reached such a distressing juncture that the community’s collective fate is brazenly framed around coercive premises: ‘Since a separate nation was carved out in the name of Islam, those who remained here must accept life as second-class citizens’, and ‘If Pakistan could be founded in the name of Islam, why shouldn’t a Hindu Rashtra be established in the name of Hindus?’

Reflecting on the psychological burden this narrative places on the community, the author noted that without access to true historical facts, even conscientious citizens are often left uncomfortable when confronted with such probing queries from fellow countrymen. For years, he harboured a profound internal conflict, mindful of the immense sacrifices rendered by Muslims during the freedom struggle—especially the tragic saga of the First War of Independence in 1857. During that dark period, freedom fighters were crushed in oil mills across the landscape from Chandni Chowk in Delhi to Lahore, and the bodies of martyrs hung from trees as grim reminders of colonial brutality. Even after enduring such devastation, following a principled and collective consensus, a vast majority of Muslims chose to remain in their homeland. Yet, when a portion of undivided India was partitioned in the name of religion, public discourse persistently questioned the moral validity of demanding equal citizenship and rights in the residual nation.

Though fundamentally flawed and unreasonable, this relentless propaganda deeply unsettled empathetic and thoughtful minds for decades. The author expressed profound gratitude to his mentor, Hazrat Maulana Khalil-ur-Rahman Sajjad Nomani, whose comprehensive lecture on the subject nearly a decade ago provided a vital paradigm shift in thought and critical analysis. Extensive reading followed, gradually dissolving the lingering, undeserved sense of collective guilt. In today’s climate—where hate-mongering elements are hyperactive and Muslim communities face constant taunts—an average citizen committed to national welfare easily falls prey to mental distress and a defensive posture. This environment pressures even the well-educated to entertain regressive notions. Consequently, uncovering hidden archival truths preserved in British libraries and independent historical records became an absolute necessity.

Unpacking the methodological challenges of historical inquiry, Al-Qasmi observed that writing history requires rigorous engagement with the works of preceding scholars. The primary challenge lies in navigating the conflicting ideological biases of historical actors and commentators to extract objective truth. Maintaining strict neutrality on a monumental tragedy like the Partition of India is exceptionally difficult, yet vital for scholarly integrity. History is not merely a chronicle of past events; it serves a higher purpose. Rather than recounting the entire chronology of independence, this study isolates a singular, crucial inquiry: Were Muslims truly the culprits of Partition, or were external and multi-party forces responsible?

Examining the multi-layered political landscape, the author noted that existing literature tends to mirror partisan narratives—British justifications, Congress frameworks, or Muslim League stances. Comprehensive works offering an inclusive Muslim perspective remain scarce, often prioritizing leadership actions while overlooking the tireless efforts of organizations like Jamiat Ulema-e-Hind to preserve a united country through workable constitutional formulas. The book endeavours to synthesize a holistic perspective, moving beyond mutual recrimination. With British archival documents now declassified, facts stand in crystal-clear clarity: the Muslims of India were not self-fragmented; rather, they were systematically partitioned under a calculated imperial strategy. Ultimately, the division weakened all parties, fracturing the largest global Muslim community since the Ottoman era. Finding answers to these foundational questions forms the bedrock of this timely research study.

source: http://www.indiatomorrow.net / India Tomorrow / Home / by Zillur Rahman Haider / October 23rd, 2026

Zafarul-Islam Khan Honoured with Shah Waliullah Award

NEW DELHI :

It is a great privilege for me to accept this honour from the Shah Waliullah Institute. Honestly, I was reluctant at first and had declined this recognition multiple times.

New Delhi :

In a momentous event, renowned Islamic scholar, author, senior journalist, and former Chairman of the Delhi Minorities Commission, Dr. Zafarul-Islam Khan, was awarded the prestigious Sixth Imam Shah Waliullah Award here on Monday. The ceremony took place amidst a distinguished seminar on the theme of ‘Epistles of Shah Waliullah’ at the Ghalib Institute here.

Jointly organized by the Shah Waliullah Institute and the Ghalib Institute, the seminar sought to celebrate and highlight the scholarly and intellectual legacy of Imam Shah Waliullah. A special highlight of the event was the launch of the tenth volume of his acclaimed series of epistles, offering attendees an intimate glimpse into his teachings and enduring contributions to Islamic sciences.

A diverse assembly of eminent scholars, intellectuals, and thinkers from across the country participated in the event, engaging in profound discussions about the contemporary relevance of Shah Waliullah’s message, writings and teachings.

Senior journalist Suhail Anjum introduced the Shah Waliullah Institute and provided an overview of the newly launched the tenth volume of Shah Waliullah’s epistles, sharing insights into the publication process, ongoing scholarly discussions and past and future programmes of the Shah Waliullah Institute.

Anjum also felicitated Mufti Ataur Rahman Qasmi highlighting his unwavering dedication to research and publish the scholarly legacy of Shah Waliullah. He highlighted Mufti Saheb’s long-standing scholarly pursuits, first as a teacher for fourteen years at the Dargah Shah Waliullah madrasah near Shah Waliullah’s shrine in Delhi’s Mehdiyan area.

During this period, Mufti Saheb developed a deep spiritual and intellectual bond with the great scholar, gaining profound insights into his contributions to Quranic sciences and other fields. Inspired by this connection, Mufti Saheb established the institute to make Shah Waliullah’s invaluable legacy accessible to all. Some of these writings were published long ago or still lie as manuscripts in libraries. Under this initiative, Mufti saheb has already published ten volumes of Shah Waliullah’s writings. The tenth volume of this series was released during the event.

Expressing humility and honour, Dr Zafarul-Islam Khan said, “It is a great privilege for me to accept this honour from the Shah Waliullah Institute. Honestly, I was reluctant at first and had declined this recognition multiple times. However, I succumbed in the face of Mufti saheb’s insistence for a number of reasons. Paramount among these is my nearly forty-year-long association with Mufti Saheb, dating back to 1984 when I returned from abroad.

At that time I visited Mehdiyan and made a spiritual bond with Shah Waliullah and with Mufti saheb who at the time taught at the madrasah there. He said that another reason is that this award is associated with Shah Waliullah, the greatest Islamic scholar produced by India. In fact, he may be regarded as the greatest non-Arab Islamic scholar of all ages. He said that long ago he wrote a modest book in Arabic on Shah Waliullah trying to attract people’s attention to the ocean of knowledge which he was and remains till this day. He said that Shah Waliullah’s monumental work Hujjatullah al-Balighah stands out as an unparalleled masterpiece in the Islamic literature. It is printed, reprinted and studied in the Arab World till this day. Dr. Khan underscored the importance of Hujjatullah al-Balighah as a treasure trove that provides a deep, balanced and comprehensive understanding of Islamic sciences.

Dr Khan commended Mufti Saheb’s tireless efforts in unearthing and publishing many of Shah Waliullah’s manuscripts and texts that were hidden and forgotten. The current tenth volume stands as a testament to this scholarly dedication. He stated that his personal and scholarly bonds with Mufti Saheb and Shah Waliullah motivated him to accept this award. He added that there is a third reason for accepting the award and that is the fact that the award is given in recognition of the Glorious Quran, his translation of the Islamic holy text which tries to offer an authentic version of the Quran based on most authentic Arabic sources.

Dr Khan said there is a great responsibility on our shoulders: to try to understand and disseminate Shah Waliullah’s teachings and present them in modern language and style. Reflecting on Shah Waliullah’s revolutionary impact, Dr. Khan highlighted his translation of the Quran into Persian—a daring act at the time, which many scholars at the time considered a blasphemy. Even today, some argue that the Quran cannot be translated into any language. But if that was true, how would the 85% of Muslims outside the Arab world understand the divine message? Therefore, it is imperative that the Quran be translated into all languages—be it Assamese, Burmese, Chinese, or any other so that the common Muslim and non-Muslim could read and understand Allah’s last message to humanity. He pointed out that Western scholars, despite their scholarly rigour, often distorted the meanings of the Quran in their translations. Therefore, it is the duty of Islamic scholars to offer correct and accurate rendering of the divine text. Dr. Khan said he dedicated eleven years to accomplish his translation of the holy Islamic text. He said he fully devoted the three years during the COVID19 pandemic to complete this work. He regarded the award as a motivation to himself and all scholars to continue scholarly pursuits.

Mufti Ataur Rahman, chairman of the Shah Waliullah Institute, addressed the gathering sharing insights into how the idea of an institute dedicated to Shah Waliullah was conceived and narrated the journey since founding the institute. He took a moment to acknowledge the previous recipients of the Shah Waliullah Award: the first was given to Maulana Abdul Karim Parekh from Nagpur in 2007; the second and third to Maulana Akhlaq Hussain Qasmi and Maulana Faqihud-Din in 2010; the fourth to Maulana Muhammad Salim Qasmi in 2013; and the fifth to Maulana Qamaruz-Zaman Ilahabadi in 2014.

The event was enriched by the presence of distinguished speakers including Muhammad Adeeb, former Member of Parliament, Mr. Siraj Hussain, former vice chancellor of Jamia Hamdard, Justice Iqbal Ahmad Ansari, former Chief Justice of Patna High Court, Prof. Khalid Mahmood and Khwaja Muhammad Shahid among others.

The proceedings were presided over by the chairman of the Ghalib Institute Prof. Siddiqur Rahman Kidwai who lauded Mufti Ataur-Rahman’s exemplary work and extended warm felicitations to Dr. Zafarul-Islam Khan for his well-earned recognition.

source: http://www.milligazette.com / The Milli Gazette / Home> News> Community News / by Zillur-Rahman Haider / June 30th, 2026